On the south side of a high bluff, over a mile behind the forts and trenches defending the
landward side of Vicksburg, and just a half mile from the riverfront
batteries holding off the Yankee navy to the west, stood a 2 story
brick mansion, one of the finest homes in Vicksburg (above). It's address was
1018 Crawford Street. Across the street stood a church, next door the Balfour Mansion.
On Sunday, 28 June, 1863 it was called “the
Willis' house”, because one of the cities' wealthiest men owned it
- grand-nephew to the town's founder, “planter” and slave owner
42 year old Thomas Vick Willis. The siege caught him away, tending to
his slaves and properties.
But up the lovely spiral staircase on the second floor resided Tom's 30
year old wife Mary with their 4 children and her slaves, all trapped
in Vicksburg because her latest pregnancy had made travel unsafe.
And
on the ground floor, in the five public rooms, resided and worked the
unhappiest man in all of Vicksburg, 48 year old Lieutenant General John
Clifford Pemberton (below).
On
this day, the General had received an extraordinary letter. How it
came into his hand is unknown, but it might have been passed to him
by the recently promoted Major General John Steven's Bowen. No author
signed the letter, although it claimed to speak for “Many Soldiers”
in the trenches. And Pemberton can have harbored little doubt that
it did. “Sir: In accordance with my own feelings,” it began, “
and that of my fellow soldiers, with whom I have conferred, I submit
to your serious consideration the following note...”
Clearly,
the author or author's knew generals, because they began by feeding
his vanity. “We, as an army,” it said, “have as much
confidence in you as a commanding general as we perhaps ought to
have. We believe you have displayed as much generalship as any other
man could have done under similar circumstances. We give you great
credit for the stern patriotism you have evinced in the defense of
Vicksburg during a protracted and unparalleled siege.”
Except, it was not an unparalleled
siege. The Roman's siege of Jerusalem in 70 A.D. lasted some 4
months, and that same year the hill top fortress of Massada held out
for about 90 days – more than twice as long as Vicksburg. King
Ferdinand and Queen Isabella had laid siege to Grenada from April
1491 to 2 January, 1492 – almost 8 months And Gibraltar had
survived its “Great” siege from 24 June, 1779 to 7 February, 1783
– 3 years and 7 months. When General Pemberton got this note,
Vicksburg had been under siege for a little over one month. And,
historically, that seems to be just about “parallel” for the
average siege.
Choosing
to ignore such unpleasant realities, the writer continued. “
I also feel proud of the gallant conduct of the soldiers under your
command in repulsing the enemy at every assault and bearing with
patient endurance all the privations and hardships incident to a
siege of forty-odd days' duration. Everybody admits that we have all
covered ourselves in glory, but, alas! alas! General, a crisis has
arrived in the midst of our siege.”
“Our rations have been cut down to
one biscuit and a small bit of bacon per day. Not enough, scarcely,
to keep soul and body together, much less to stand the hardships we
are called upon to stand.” The writer noted, “...there is
complaining and general dissatisfaction through out our lines.” The
cause of all this was obvious. “Men don't want to starve,” warned
the writer, “ and don't intend to, but they call upon you for
justice...” Soldiers asking a commanding general for justice was
coming close to insubordination. Still, the writer forged ahead. “The
emergency of the case demands prompt and decided action on your part.
If you can't feed us, you had better surrender us.”
This clearly was
insubordination, and maybe even treason. But, warned the author,
“Horrible as the idea is, (better this) than suffer this noble army
to disgrace themselves by desertion.” Arguing these were “stubborn
facts” the author insisted, “ I tell you plainly, men are not
going to lie here and perish... hunger will compel a man to do
almost anything. You had better heed a warning voice, though it is
the voice of a private soldier. This army is now ripe for mutiny,
unless it can be fed.”
The
grammar was too perfect to be that of a “private soldier.” General Pemberton (above) would have surely recognized that instantly. And
there are no signatures on the single surviving copy. So why did
Pemberton preserve this note? We are told it was found in his private
papers after the siege. Perhaps it was to be used as evidence at a
court martial. There was another possibility, of course. The letter may
have come from the other side of the trenches. The Army of the
Tennessee knew perfectly well the conditions inside Vicksburg, as Mr.
Dana's message to Stanton and Lincoln revealed. This note might have been Yankee “psy-op”, and if it was, that would hold its own
specific dread for the commander of the “American Gibraltar”. A
hungry army is no threat to the enemy if the enemy knows how hungry they are.
By
the end of June it was obvious to everyone that every warning General Joseph Johnston had issued about Vicksburg had come true.
And as "Old Joe" had warned, the key to
Vicksburg was not the trench lines or the fortifications or the water
batteries, not the Warren County Court house atop the highest hill in
the city of hills. The key to Vicksburg was Snyder's Bluff, and Chickasaw Bayou six miles
away. And just as Johnston had said, once that position fell, Vicksburg could not be held.
And as Joe Johnston had pointed out, having
lost the long bridge over the Pearl River south of Jackson, any practical
reason for holding Snyder's Bluff was also lost.
Since 1832 railroad
engineers had known it took only 8 pounds of force to start 1 ton of
cargo moving on rails. And once the “track resistance” - inertia
– was overcome the heavier the train, the lower the cost to move a pound
of cargo on that train. A 30 horsepower engine could keep a 70 ton train moving at
20 miles per hour – the distance a horse drawn wagon might cover in
a good day – for as long as the fuel lasted. Any connection between
the Confederacy and the Trans-Mississippi Confederacy, between the state of Mississippi and the government in Richmond Virginia not via rail
lines, was an illusion.
It was a lesson General Pemberton should have understood before he allowed himself to be trapped in Vicksburg, Certainly, it was an idea he understood now, as June faded into July.